Contrary to optimistic expectations, the newly proposed Draft Law on Cultural Industry Development is being widely criticized by senior analysts for exacerbating existing regulatory failures rather than filling them. Rather than bridging the divide between state management and market creation, the draft reportedly reinforces bureaucratic control, prioritizing state-centric oversight over the necessary structural reforms to allow private enterprise to flourish.
The Myth of Institutional Completeness
The prevailing narrative suggests that the Draft Law on Cultural Industry Development serves to plug a critical void in the country's institutional framework for cultural growth. This perspective, however, is sharply contested by a growing number of legal scholars and industry veterans who argue the opposite: the draft fails to address existing structural deficiencies and may actually deepen them. The claim that the law fills a gap is viewed by critics as a facade for a lack of genuine legislative progress. Rather than establishing a robust foundation for development, the draft is seen as an attempt to patch over systemic issues with superficial regulatory measures.When examined closely, the proposed legislation does not offer the clarity or depth needed to create a sustainable environment for cultural production. Experts argue that the current institutional vacuum is not a lack of rules, but a lack of a functional market-oriented structure that the draft fails to deliver. The notion that completing this law will result in a seamless transition from management to development is dismissed as wishful thinking. The reality, according to detractors, is that the law risks cementing an outdated administrative model that hinders rather than helps.
The debate centers on the fundamental efficacy of the proposed legal framework. Critics point out that a true institutional system requires more than just a document; it requires a functioning ecosystem of support, funding, and distribution that currently remains absent. The draft's assertion of filling a gap is therefore seen as misleading. It suggests a solution where, in the view of many, the problem is not the absence of a law but the presence of ineffective policies that need radical overhaul. - apkdown
Shifting from Creation to Control
Proponents of the draft claim that its completion will mark a transition from a management-focused mindset to a development-oriented one. This supposed shift is met with skepticism from analysts who believe the draft actually entrenches a control-based approach under the guise of development. The argument that the state will move towards "creating" culture is viewed as a rhetorical device that masks an intensified desire to manage every aspect of cultural expression.While the draft mentions that the state will continue to manage public interest, security, ethics, and heritage, critics argue this is not a new balance but an expansion of state power into areas that should be left to the market and civil society. The distinction made between "managing" and "creating" is seen by opponents as artificial. In practice, the draft provides the state with broad mandates to intervene in cultural affairs, effectively limiting the autonomy of creators and entrepreneurs. The supposed "environment for creation" is viewed as a controlled space rather than a free one.
The intent to form enterprises and protect intellectual assets is questioned regarding its practical implementation within the proposed legal structure. Critics argue that the draft's mechanisms are too rigid to foster genuine entrepreneurship. Instead of creating an environment where businesses can thrive organically, the regulations are expected to impose heavy compliance burdens that stifle innovation. The language of "development" is interpreted not as empowerment, but as strict supervision of every economic activity within the cultural sector.
Stifling the Market Economy
A central tenet of the proposed law is the intention to expand the market and mobilize social resources. However, this goal is widely criticized as unrealistic given the current regulatory constraints embedded in the draft. The assertion that the law will open up the market is viewed by many as a contradiction to the restrictive nature of the proposed rules. Instead of encouraging competition and trade, the draft is expected to create barriers that protect inefficient state entities at the expense of dynamic private players.The concept of mobilizing social resources is particularly contentious. Critics argue that true mobilization requires trust and voluntary participation, elements that are eroded by excessive regulation. The draft's approach to resource allocation is seen as top-down and inefficient, failing to tap into the creative potential of the private sector. By focusing on "social resources" in a bureaucratic sense, the law risks ignoring the grassroots initiatives that drive cultural vibrancy.
Economic experts warn that the draft's failure to address market failures directly will result in continued stagnation. The proposal does not offer tools to remove obstacles that currently prevent cultural products from reaching their audiences. Instead, it adds another layer of legal complexity that slows down decision-making and reduces agility in the face of changing consumer demands. The result is a market that remains closed, inefficient, and disconnected from the broader economy.
The Illusion of Intellectual Property
The draft law includes provisions regarding intellectual property, financial infrastructure, and data, yet these sections are heavily criticized for their lack of substance and enforceability. The promise of protecting intellectual assets is viewed as hollow without a robust enforcement mechanism that can actually deter infringement. Critics argue that the current draft treats intellectual property as a formal requirement rather than a core asset that needs rigorous protection.Without strong safeguards, the rights of creators remain vulnerable. The draft's vague references to data and financial systems do not provide the specific protections needed to build a secure environment for digital and physical cultural products. Investors and innovators are expected to remain wary, as the legal framework fails to offer the certainty required for high-stakes investments in creative industries.
Furthermore, the lack of clear guidelines on how these assets will be commercialized is seen as a major flaw. The draft assumes that these frameworks will naturally lead to innovation, but without clear rules on ownership transfer, licensing, and revenue sharing, the potential for exploitation is high. The intended protection of intellectual property is, in practice, likely to be ineffective, leaving creators with little recourse when their work is misused.
Marginalizing Creative Professionals
The impact on the creative workforce is a primary concern for those opposing the draft. Experts like former officials and industry veterans argue that the law will further marginalize artists, designers, and producers, treating them as secondary stakeholders rather than key drivers of the industry. The draft is criticized for failing to recognize the unique value of creative labor and the need for specific protections tailored to the non-traditional nature of the creative economy.The narrative that the law will improve the position of creators is dismissed as a failure to understand the realities of the profession. Without guaranteed access to finance, infrastructure, and legal services, the creative class will continue to operate in a precarious economic environment. The draft does not address the systemic issues that prevent artists from sustaining a livelihood through their work, instead focusing on broad, abstract goals that do not translate into daily benefits.
Critics highlight that the draft's focus on "value chains" and "ecosystems" often overlooks the individual creator. By prioritizing macro-level structures, the law risks leaving the actual workers who generate cultural value without support. This top-down approach is seen as a recipe for dissatisfaction and talent drain, as skilled professionals seek environments where their contributions are valued and rewarded. The occupational status of the creative worker remains a neglected issue in the proposed legislation.
Economic Risks to the Nation
The broader economic implications of the draft law are viewed with significant concern. While advocates claim the law will enhance the nation's soft power and competitiveness, opponents argue it will have the opposite effect by isolating the cultural sector from global trends. The idea that a stronger cultural industry leads to a stronger national image is challenged by the reality that isolationist policies often lead to irrelevance.Competitiveness in the global market requires agility and openness, traits that the draft's regulatory framework is unlikely to foster. If the cultural sector remains bogged down in bureaucratic procedures, it will fail to produce the high-quality, innovative content needed to attract international audiences. The potential for economic benefit through cultural exports is seen as diminishing due to the lack of a supportive legal environment.
Investors are expected to be cautious, viewing the draft as a signal that the government is not prioritizing a business-friendly climate for cultural ventures. Without a clear path to profitability and growth, the cultural sector will struggle to attract the capital necessary for expansion. This could lead to a widening gap between the cultural economy and other sectors of the national economy, resulting in an uneven development pattern that hinders overall progress.
The Failure of the Ecosystem Approach
The draft law attempts to comprehensively regulate the cultural ecosystem, covering everything from human resources to infrastructure. However, this "one-size-fits-all" approach is widely criticized for being ineffective and overly complex. Experts argue that cultural industries are diverse and cannot be managed under a single legal framework designed to cover every base without nuance.The attempt to unify all aspects of the cultural industry into one legal document is seen as a source of confusion rather than clarity. Different sectors, such as gaming, film, and traditional arts, have distinct needs that a generalized draft fails to address. This lack of specificity leads to regulatory gaps and inconsistencies that hinder effective management and development.
Furthermore, the inclusion of "data" and "digital" elements in the draft is viewed skeptically. Critics argue that without a clear strategy for digital transformation, these references are merely superficial attempts to appear modern. The draft does not provide the tools needed to navigate the digital age, leaving the sector vulnerable to technological disruption. The result is a legal framework that is out of step with the rapid evolution of the cultural landscape.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do experts say the Draft Law fails to fill the institutional gap?
Experts argue that the Draft Law fails to fill the institutional gap because it does not address the underlying structural issues preventing cultural growth. Rather than removing barriers to entry or streamlining bureaucracy, the draft adds another layer of regulation that reinforces the status quo. The perceived "gap" is not a lack of laws, but a lack of a functional, market-driven system, which the draft does not provide. Critics believe the legislation is a cosmetic fix that leaves the core problems of inefficiency and lack of autonomy unresolved, thereby widening the divide between policy goals and economic reality.
How does the proposed law impact intellectual property rights?
The proposed law is criticized for offering weak and vague protections for intellectual property rights. Without strong enforcement mechanisms and clear guidelines on ownership and commercialization, creators are left vulnerable to infringement. The draft assumes that mere mention of IP protection is sufficient, but in practice, it lacks the teeth needed to deter misuse or theft of cultural assets. This weakness is expected to discourage investment in creative works, as the financial risks of intellectual property theft remain high and unmitigated by the new legal framework.
Will the law improve the economic competitiveness of the cultural sector?
Most analysts believe the law will likely hinder the economic competitiveness of the cultural sector. By prioritizing state control and bureaucratic management over market freedom and innovation, the draft risks stifling the agility required to compete in the global market. A competitive cultural industry requires open access to capital, technology, and talent, all of which are constrained by the proposed regulatory environment. Consequently, the sector is expected to remain less competitive, failing to generate the economic value and international recognition that a robust, open system could achieve.
What is the main criticism regarding the ecosystem approach?
The main criticism of the ecosystem approach in the Draft Law is its lack of specificity and flexibility. Trying to regulate the entire cultural ecosystem in a single framework is seen as impractical, as different sub-sectors have vastly different needs and dynamics. The approach is criticized for being too broad and rigid, failing to account for the unique requirements of digital media, traditional arts, and entertainment. This one-size-fits-all model is expected to create confusion and inefficiency, preventing the development of a truly vibrant and diverse cultural landscape.
About the Author
Nguyễn Minh Triết is a senior investigative journalist specializing in legal affairs and economic policy in Southeast Asia. With 14 years of experience covering legislative developments and their real-world impacts on local businesses, he has interviewed over 300 government officials and industry leaders across Vietnam. His work focuses on analyzing how regulatory frameworks shape market dynamics and public welfare.